Are you incorporated yet?
July 25, 2011 Leave a comment
For those of you who don’t study the HMRC ‘Rates and Allowances’ archive and compare tax rates, you may not be aware of the historical tax rates paid by companies and the self employed. In the ‘olden’ days the break even point of incorporation was probably up at around the £50,000 mark, but more recently this has now almost certainly changed…..
With the latest changes in the tax rates from the last budget now in full effect, limited companies are now paying corporation tax at 20%, which is now the same rate at which the self employed pay their income tax at the basic rate. Whereas companies have to wait till their profits reach £300,000 before their tax rates are increased, the self employed have their tax rate hiked up to 40% when their earnings reach £35,000 and then again to 50% at £150,000.
And then of course you then have to take into account the National Insurance charges for the self employed, which have now risen from 8% to 9% for basic rate tax payers and from 1% to 2% for higher rate tax payers. So whereas historically incorporation only became a ‘no brainer’ if you were a higher rate tax payer, the 9% tax differential for basic rate tax payers means even they could be thousands of pounds better off by incorporating.
All businesses should consider incorporation whatever the profit, but incorporation is not easy. So apart from saving money what are the other benefits to incorporation and what are the practical issues that a business needs to consider before taking the plunge?
Benefits
- Reduction in tax bill – basic rate tax payers at least 9% better off, higher rate tax payers much more so.
- Limited liability – before the benefit in tax reduction this was the main reason for incorporation because should a company fail the liability of the shareholder is supposedly limited to the amount unpaid on the shares (if any).
- The word ‘Limited’ may provide enhanced status.
- Different categories of shares can enable different levels of payment to be allocated; advantage being taken of the different personal tax circumstances of individual shareholders.
- Dividend waivers enable transfer of income – possibly from a higher rate tax payer to lower rate. Not possible to transfer income of self-employed unless a partnership is formed.
- IHT Planning – a company enables greater flexibility; on death the company continues to exist as a separate legal entity.
- Depending upon the type of business it might prove easier to sell shares rather than the business and business assets if not a Limited company.
- Tax free employee benefits and incentives can be provided with the company obtaining tax relief thereon – not possible for the self-employed employer
- Where the business property is held outside of the company in the directors name the director can extract funds from the company in the form of rent – no PAYE or NIC issues. There will usually be a mortgage such that rental income will ensure immediate tax relief for interest paid. No Entrepreneurs Relief is due on the sale of the property as it will be deemed an investment property.
- Overlap relief available on cessation of self-employed trade.
- Transfer of trading loss – relieved against salary then against dividends so long as business exchanged for shares. At least 75% of the shares of company must be retained by the shareholder throughout the tax year in which the loss is relieved. (S86 ITA 2007)
Practical issues
- Be careful to calculate best date for cessation of self-employment – choosing the wrong date may increase tax liability for the final year.
- Some companies in regulated industries may be required to apply for new licenses as the status of the business has changed.
- Consider whether it would be more beneficial for cars to be held in the director’s personal name outside of the company – calculation as to benefit in kind and Capital Allowance etc. needed. Company cars are no longer tax efficient now that they must be pooled with other plant so unless the car is of low emission the figures will probably show that it is best to keep car out of company. Will leasing the car be an alternative?
- Turnover of a company in excess of £6.5m requires audited accounts; no such requirement for self-employed.
- Care is needed where there is the prospect of the shares being transferred or disposed of within two years of incorporation (Business Property Relief)
- IR 35 ‘personal service’ legislation issues for ‘knowledge based’ businesses.
- Consideration is needed as to the method of transfer of business i.e. via use of ‘Incorporation’ relief (s162 TCGA 1992) or ‘Hold Over’ relief (s165 TCGA 1992). ‘Hold over relief’ is automatically applied by HMRC if the relevant criteria are met therefore suggest write to HMRC confirming position. If the business was set up post 1 April 2002 the cost for goodwill is allowed to be amortised in accordance with accounting practice against the company’s profits; if the goodwill was created pre 1 April 2002 no relief is allowed. The owner can claim Entrepreneurs’ relief on the sale of the business and should full relief not be possible tax is charged at the beneficial rate of 10%.
- The most difficult issue to deal with is the valuation of goodwill – best to use a specialist valuer.
About the author: Richard Jepson ACCA is the Tax Manager at Adams and Moore. For more information or to make an enquiry contact Richard@adamsandmoore.co.uk









